## In 200-300 words minimum, please respond to ONE of the following discussion questions.  You will want to provide a thesis and use quotations (with an in-text citation and reference) to support your response.  Please respond to one of the initial questions by Thursday (6/12) to allow classmates to respond to your post.

## Then, respond to at least two of your classmates' posts.  The responses to classmates should be a minimum of 100 words.

### Explain the conclusion drawn by Plato at the end of his "Allegory of the Cave" where he states that the only ones who should be entrusted to rule over the state are those least interested in power. Why is it the duty of the enlightened one to return to the cave and what will the prisoners' responses likely be?

In Plato's Allegory of the Cave imagines prisoners who have never experienced anything beyond the cave in which they are imprisoned. To them, their cave and the shadows are reality - and everything else is false. 

Should a person be forced to the real world, Plato argues that they will initially resist new knowledge, and the pain of the light, but will eventually realize the truth of what the shadows were. 

The enlightened person then must go back to the cave to show how things "really are", only to be met with incredulity and disbelief. Their inability to accept a new reality beyond that which is useful to them in the cave prevents them from accepting the truth. By going back to the cave, the enlightened person gains nothing, but must anyways because of his duty to the fellow cave dwellers.

Similarly, the philosopher king is obligated to a vision for the nation and want to improve it in the same way that the enlightened person is obligated to return to the cave. More so, the philosopher king should not perceive any direct benefit to themselves by returning to the cave, and return out of duty rather than superiority. Thus, the ones who are not interested in the power but rather by their vision for the world are those most suited to rule.

### Response #1

I agree with the idea that the two systems had differing levels of 
participation. I believe that the context of the two systems greatly 
impacts the styles of the two systems. Athens, before the hellenistic 
age was one of the poli of Greece, and thus could use a purely 
democratic system - The Athenian Assembly. In contrast, Rome was a vast 
empire, which spanned a large majority of Europe, and thus needed a more
 decentralized system of government through sheer size alone. The 
Athenians may have had a more representative system, but I feel that 
their limited population and limited geographical size make them 
incomparable as government systems.

### Response #2

The differences between the two epic poems also gives a better idea of the values of the cultures. Both cultures clearly valued heroism, and reflect this in their stories. Gilgamesh's initial state as a tyrant shows that the quality of rule was an important part of Sumerian life, and that the ideal king is one who can rule perpetually wisely - as reflected by his search for immortality. The story focuses on overcoming internal biases and forces to become a better person. Comparatively, the story of Achilles does not discuss rulership or kingdoms, and focuses instead on adventure and overcoming external forces.
