Course Feedback
The discussions we had before and after class about how we were teaching our classes were the most helpful. Often, the barrier to being a good TA is not a lack of ability, but a lack of desire to put in the effort, and discussing in-person with people is always motivating.
The current course feels designed to cover liability for the university rather than to actually teach. A short course on Brightspace would serve the same purpose. What would feel more motivating to show up to in every lecture would be to have a series of discussion on CS Education papers, invited talks from CS Education researchers who can explain what is in the field and what is next, etc.
I think this course would have been much more interesting and relevant if it drew from the CS literature. CS Education is a fairly old and relatively interesting field. Most of the work is focused on teaching more broadly, but the range of CS courses is broad, and the expectations of a TA are clear. Spending just one class on the expectations from TAs and the dismissal conditions, one on FERPA, and spending the rest of the half-semester discussing the literature would have been much more interesting for grad students. Being able to communicate, research or simpler, is a huge part of what it means to be a scientist. Being taught those skills, especially in the familiar context of the classroom is a useful skill.
Discussion helps us set a benchmark against our peers of what the classroom is meant for. It is also more engaging than lecture content, even if each class takes longer. I would also not make attendance mandatory, and instead just make some number of discussion mandatory.
I would also remove the online discussion posts. They don’t take much time, but they do turn into work which feels redundant very easily, which is less productive. The readings on starting grad school were interesting, but would have been better with another lecture from the CS GSB on that subject, potentially with a panel discussion.
Being forced to give a presentation would be one way to make the course more educational, although the quality would be varied based on the interest of the people involved.